Monday, November 16, 2026

Jensen Huang -- A Case of Racial Resentment of Chinese Success

 

Chinese Achievement Under Suspicion

Jensen Huang, Qian Xuesen, and the Unresolved Roles of Security Concern, Racial Prejudice, and Strategic Accusation

November 16, 2026

The United States has repeatedly celebrated scientists and entrepreneurs of Chinese heritage for their contributions to American power—only to regard their proximity to China as a source of suspicion when geopolitical anxiety intensifies.

Abstract

This essay examines whether the November 2026 treatment of Nvidia cofounder Jensen Huang echoes features of the Cold War ordeal of rocket scientist Qian Xuesen: insinuations of foreign allegiance can outrun proof, while sensational coverage converts uncertainty into reputational damage. The episodes are not equivalent. Qian suffered direct state detention and restrictions; Huang resigned amid a mixture of verified personal misconduct, unresolved intelligence suspicions, and corporate-governance questions. The comparison is nevertheless illuminating because it exposes how the burden of proving loyalty can fall especially heavily on Chinese and Chinese-American figures at the center of strategic technologies. It situates both cases within a longer history of anti-Chinese prejudice while distinguishing possible motives: sincerely held security concerns, racial resentment, strategically deployed suspicion, or some combination. The available evidence cannot assign any one motive to all the actors involved, and the strategic-use hypothesis requires investigation rather than assumption. The essay further examines the potential for defamation liability when outlets or commentators adopt demonstrably false allegations, drawing a careful distinction between the Fox–Dominion litigation and the still-unresolved Huang controversy.

The thesis: suspicion is not evidence

A nation is entitled to protect legitimate national-security secrets. Its journalists are entitled to investigate powerful executives. Its corporate boards are entitled to enforce rules of conduct. None of those propositions licenses a leap from Chinese connections to Chinese espionage, or from overseas GPU access to illegal physical diversion.

Such leaps matter particularly in the case of Jensen Huang, who cofounded Nvidia in 1993 and helped turn programmable GPUs and accelerated computing into the infrastructure of modern artificial intelligence. Calling him the “father of the AI industry” is an honorific, not a literal claim of sole authorship: AI rests on generations of work by researchers, engineers, universities, and competitors. Yet Huang's role in creating the industrial platform for the current AI revolution is exceptional.[1]

In November 2026, the public watched that achievement become entangled with headlines about a “suspected Chinese spy.” The critical issue is not whether Huang deserves immunity from scrutiny; he does not. It is whether ethnicity, nationality, and geopolitical association have been used to construct a dramatic narrative in advance of sufficient proof—and, if so, whether that resulted from genuine concern, prejudice, deliberate strategy, or overlapping causes.

Qian Xuesen: America's rocket pioneer turned security suspect

Qian Xuesen (Tsien Hsue-shen), a Chinese-born aerodynamicist educated at MIT and Caltech, was a formative figure in American jet-propulsion and rocket research. He worked with Theodore von Kármán, helped establish the research tradition from which the Jet Propulsion Laboratory emerged, contributed to wartime U.S. aerospace research, and held high-level security clearances. He was a pioneer of American rocket science—although the broader field also had indispensable figures such as Robert Goddard and other early rocketry researchers.[2]

During the anti-communist panic of 1950, Qian lost his clearance amid suspicions of Communist Party ties. The U.S. government restricted his travel; he endured detention, surveillance, and years of confinement-like restrictions while legal and diplomatic disputes unfolded. His colleagues, including Caltech leadership, defended him. In 1955 he was permitted to depart for China, where he became a founding architect of its missile and space programs.[2]

“It was the stupidest thing this country ever did.”Attributed by Caltech's historical account to Navy Under Secretary Dan Kimball, reflecting on Qian's treatment. [2]

The Qian case embodies two failures. The first was procedural: suspicion and disputed political association overwhelmed the fair assessment of an individual. The second was strategic: in treating a valuable scientist as presumptively alien, the United States helped transfer extraordinary expertise to a geopolitical rival. Historical evidence of the government's suspicions exists; the injustice was not that officials asked questions, but that the measures imposed were deeply consequential and remain contested as justified responses.[2][3]

Jensen Huang: a 21st-century loyalty drama

On November 11, 2026, Nvidia's board accepted Huang's resignation as president, chief executive, and director. Nvidia's SEC filing establishes the resignation as fact; the filing does not establish that Huang knowingly assisted espionage or unlawful chip diversion.[4]

Reporting described an extramarital relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive associated with Megaspeed International, a Singapore-based computing business. Jensen Huang acknowledged marital infidelity. That conduct can properly invite private, ethical, and corporate scrutiny—particularly if conflicts of interest or disclosure duties were implicated. But an affair, however damaging personally, is not evidence of espionage.[5]

The national-security allegation remained unsettled even as the scandal accelerated. CNN reported on November 12 that intelligence already collected, including intercepted communications, did not prove Alice Huang was knowingly acting as a Chinese spy; it also reported disagreement among U.S. officials. Attorney General Todd Blanche stated that the Justice Department had reached no conclusion on whether she was a spy. The reporting also described intelligence concerns that officials considered significant; those concerns cannot simply be dismissed, but neither should they be promoted to verdicts.[6][7]

Singapore's Ministry of Home Affairs separately stated that Alice Huang was not investigated for espionage in Singapore. Its police concluded in February 2026 that there was insufficient evidence to establish her involvement in suspected false-declaration offenses concerning server purchases. Singapore also said she knowingly provided inaccurate information about her Megaspeed role, for which she was warned and barred from re-entry. The wider Megaspeed investigation remains open. An honest account must include both exculpatory and adverse findings.[8]

Key evidentiary boundary

No publicly established finding as of November 16 proves that Alice Huang was a Chinese spy, that Megaspeed unlawfully transported Nvidia GPUs into mainland China, or that Jensen Huang knowingly participated in either activity. That is a statement about the public evidentiary record, not a claim to know everything classified investigators possess.

How headlines can turn uncertainty into guilt

The clearest criticism of the coverage concerns its language and framing. For example, the Los Angeles Times wrote on November 12 that intelligence agencies had “determined” Alice Huang was feeding information to Beijing, attributing the assertion to a New York Times report. That phrasing conveys a definitive intelligence conclusion. Yet CNN's same-day reporting documented disagreement and an absence of proof sufficient to convince important intelligence officials. Both reports may faithfully reflect different sources; their juxtaposition nevertheless shows why readers needed prominent caveats, not merely sensational association.[9][6]

Some headlines attached the phrase “Chinese spy” directly to the intimate relationship even while investigations remained unresolved. In a digital information economy, the label may propagate much faster than subsequent uncertainty or correction. Readers who see a headline but not the caveats can carry away an impression of proven guilt.

There is an additional issue of narrative selection. The image of a powerful Chinese-heritage technology leader, a Chinese businesswoman, advanced AI chips, and Beijing offers a remarkably compact espionage story. Each association may be newsworthy. But their combination does not itself form an evidentiary chain. To establish the more serious accusation, investigators would need evidence of actual intelligence tasking, disclosure, transmission, or knowing involvement—not merely photographs, business contacts, or nationality.

It would be unsound to assert that every American outlet knowingly lied, or that journalists' race explains their conduct. CNN, Reuters and other U.S.-based news organizations themselves reported the uncertainty and obtained contrary evidence. The stronger, demonstrable indictment concerns particular headlines, sourcing choices, and failures to distinguish allegation from adjudicated fact. Criticism should target those decisions, not racial categories.

The technical error: renting CUDA is not shipping GPUs

Export-control discourse risks another category error. A Chinese company may obtain computational output from GPU hardware operating in a foreign data center without importing that hardware into mainland China. The physical location of the accelerator, the entity controlling it, the service supplied, and the applicable export restrictions are distinct legal and technical questions.

Physical diversion would require evidence of shipments or prohibited transfers, and the relevant law would need to be applied to actual parties and transactions. Remote access to an overseas CUDA service is not itself proof that the underlying chips crossed an embargoed border. Some remote-compute arrangements may nonetheless fall within applicable restrictions, depending on end user, end use, ownership, dates, and regulatory changes. It is therefore also wrong to pronounce every cloud-service transaction categorically lawful without examining its terms.

Singapore confirmed that investigators were looking into whether servers exported through Singapore to Malaysia had subsequently been rerouted contrary to declarations. It did not announce that Alice Huang had committed the suspected server-declaration offenses; its broader investigation remains ongoing. Nvidia and Megaspeed have denied knowledge of or participation in illicit diversion. Allegations from anonymous sources deserve scrutiny, but an allegation is not a confirmed customs trail.[8][10]

The methodological principle is simple: if a report asserts that chips entered China, it should identify what establishes their physical movement. If it instead documents Chinese use of offshore compute, it should say exactly that.

Two eras, one recurring suspicion

DimensionQian Xuesen, 1950–55Jensen Huang, 2026
Strategic technologyRocket propulsion, missiles, aerospaceGPU acceleration and industrial AI infrastructure
Public suspicionCommunist affiliation and political loyaltyChinese intelligence contacts and chip diversion
Institutional responseClearance revocation, detention, surveillance, travel restrictionsCorporate investigation and resignation; public law-enforcement scrutiny
Proof at issueDisputed historical basis for political-security allegations and severity of measuresNo public finding establishing Huang's espionage or illegal diversion
Material differenceDirect coercive state actionBoard decision plus public pressure; no comparable detention
Potential costLoss of rocket expertise to ChinaLeadership disruption at a central AI company; ultimate consequences not yet known

This comparison identifies common mechanisms of suspicion; it does not claim equivalent legal procedures, proven racial motives, or identical outcomes.

Qian's ordeal is a warning against a national-security culture that can make ancestry and association seem like substitutes for individual evidence. Huang's case poses the analogous challenge for a new technological era: will a society distinguish genuine security risk from the seductive ease of telling a Chinese-espionage story about a globally connected industry?

The deeper structure: racial resentment of Chinese success

The problem is not only whether a Chinese-born scientist or Chinese-American entrepreneur is suspected of disloyalty. It is also what happens when the person's success itself becomes intolerable to those who imagine American achievement as a possession of white Americans.

From useful labor to unwanted competitors

Anti-Chinese prejudice is not a speculative addition to American history. It appears in law, political agitation, labor campaigns, and violence. Chinese laborers helped construct the transcontinental railroad and develop the American West, yet their growing participation in the economy helped provoke a backlash. The U.S. State Department's historical account explicitly describes rising anti-Chinese sentiment as Chinese workers became successful and some established businesses of their own. The National Archives identifies labor competition and nativism as central forces behind the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882—legislation that restricted Chinese immigration and denied Chinese people an ordinary path to naturalization.[11][12]

The historical pattern is particularly revealing: Chinese people were valued when their work served American expansion, but some white Americans treated them as an economic and cultural danger when they became visible competitors. Racial resentment was not simply fear of difference. It also concerned status, ownership, and who was entitled to prosper.

The racist does not need to deny a Chinese American's brilliance. The brilliance itself can become the grievance: proof that someone regarded as an outsider has attained power, wealth, or prestige that the racist believes should belong to “people like us.”

Success without belonging: the perpetual-foreigner trap

This contradiction remains recognizable in the paired stereotypes of the “model minority” and the “perpetual foreigner.” Asian Americans can be praised for technical ability while simultaneously being treated as alien to the national community. In a Pew Research Center survey, 78% of Asian American adults reported at least one of the listed incidents suggestive of foreigner treatment; 32% said someone had told them to return to their “home country.” These are reports of lived experiences, not measurements of the motives of every American.[13]

Experimental and survey research supplies evidence of the mechanism. A 2022 study involving 1,323 white American participants found Asian targets were consistently rated as less American than white targets. Participants who blamed China for COVID-19 were more likely to apply the perpetual-foreigner stereotype. This is evidence of a measurable bias among the studied participants, not proof that all white Americans—or any named reporter—harbor the same prejudice.[14]

Why technological leadership can intensify resentment

Qian and Huang occupy fields central to national prestige. Their achievements make racialized suspicion especially consequential: the more indispensable the Chinese figure becomes, the sharper the contradiction for an observer who conflates “American” with “white” and “Chinese ancestry” with foreign allegiance. In that mindset, success does not settle the question of belonging; it heightens the perceived threat. The political vocabulary changes—from communism and missiles to AI, GPUs, and espionage—but the implicit question can remain: How did a Chinese person come to command something so important to America?

Seen in this historical light, the repeated insinuation that Huang's commercial networks or personal associations must conceal allegiance to China warrants scrutiny. The mere fact that his company does business across borders, or that Chinese firms rent overseas computing power, cannot answer that question. To do so is to substitute ancestry and economic competition for specific evidence. Yet this is an interpretive lens, not a demonstrated explanation of any individual board member's, journalist's, or official's decision in the Huang affair.

A distinction that makes the criticism stronger

Racism can be entrenched in institutions and recurring narratives without constituting a universal trait of white Americans. White journalists, lawyers, scientists, and neighbors have also challenged exclusion and defended Chinese Americans, just as others sustained those exclusions. The claim this essay advances is both more precise and more serious: American history contains a durable repertoire of anti-Chinese resentment, and the celebration of Chinese achievement can coexist with a willingness to cast its achievers as perpetual outsiders. In the present controversy, that repertoire is a reason to insist on proof—not to assume that every unfavorable report is racially motivated.

Potential legal liability: the press, its amplifiers, and the Fox–Dominion precedent

Constitutional press freedom is indispensable, especially when reporting on powerful executives and security agencies. But it is not an immunity from civil liability for publishing materially false factual allegations. The relevant question is not whether a story is hostile to Jensen Huang or Alice Huang. It is whether an identifiable publisher or speaker communicated a false and defamatory factual assertion about a specific person, and did so with the degree of fault the law requires. Depending on jurisdiction and the plaintiff's status, additional questions include privileges, proof of harm, retractions, limitations periods, and the precise meaning a reasonable audience would attribute to the challenged words.[15]

Fox News and Dominion: a warning, not an automatic analogy

In US Dominion, Inc. v. Fox News Network, LLC, the Delaware Superior Court ruled on March 31, 2023 that the contested statements alleging Dominion had manipulated the 2020 presidential election were false and defamatory per se. The court also found publication by Fox News Network but held that contested issues of actual malice still required resolution by a jury. Before that trial occurred, Fox agreed in April 2023 to pay Dominion $787.5 million to settle the case. The settlement was not a jury verdict finding that Fox acted with actual malice. Its importance is that a major media defendant faced extraordinary financial exposure after a court determined the core factual claims were false, while internal evidence about knowledge and doubt remained central to the unresolved liability question.[16][17]

Fox–Dominion also illustrates why a broadcaster cannot necessarily avoid liability by providing a microphone for other speakers. In its earlier ruling denying dismissal, the Delaware court considered allegations that Fox hosts endorsed the purported fraud claims, skewed their questioning, and failed to convey information contradicting the story. Such behavior may matter to a neutral-reporting defense and to the evidence of knowledge or recklessness; merely interviewing a source or accurately reporting that an allegation exists is a different act from adopting that allegation as fact.[18]

The constitutional hurdle: public figures and actual malice

Jensen Huang is very likely a public figure for purposes of reporting on his leadership and professional conduct. Under New York Times Co. v. Sullivan and its public-figure progeny, he would ordinarily have to prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant published a false defamatory statement with actual malice—knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth. Actual malice is a demanding constitutional term, not mere hostility, partisan intent, racial animus, careless editing, or a desire for clicks. A failure to investigate, by itself, generally will not suffice. Deliberately avoiding obvious evidence that a serious allegation may be false can, in appropriate circumstances, support the inference.[15][19]

Alice Huang's status would require a separate, fact-specific inquiry. She may not be a general-purpose public figure, even if controversy has made her a prominent subject of coverage. Whether she is a limited-purpose public figure, and for which issues, can affect the required showing of fault. That assessment cannot be borrowed automatically from Jensen Huang's fame.

Accusations, insinuations, headlines, and repetition

Four situations demand special attention. First, declaring that someone is a spy or smuggled GPUs is a potentially verifiable accusation of serious wrongdoing. Second, accurately saying that named officials suspect espionage may convey a true fact about an investigation, although the whole publication must still be assessed for misleading factual implication and applicable privileges. Third, presenting an allegedly defamatory factual charge as an “opinion” does not automatically protect it: Milkovich v. Lorain Journal rejected an absolute exemption for opinions that imply provably false facts. Fourth, an on-air guest, commentator, podcaster, or online amplifier who independently adopts and republishes a defamatory factual allegation may face exposure under applicable law; repeating “someone says” is not a universal legal shield. Nevertheless, neutral and accurate coverage of official proceedings can enjoy important protections, and each republication must be evaluated individually.[20][16]

A hypothetical headline saying “Investigators examine alleged Chinese intelligence contacts” communicates a different factual proposition from “Jensen Huang enabled Chinese espionage.” If the first is properly sourced and accurately describes the investigation, it may be fully defensible. If the second is false, its publisher knew it was unsupported or seriously doubted it, and the other elements are met, the legal risk is much greater. Neither formulation is presented here as a quotation from any actual outlet.

What a legally serious inquiry would require

A possible defamation case would begin with an exact, dated inventory of statements—not a generalized complaint that American media were unfair. For each statement, a claimant would need to identify the publisher and responsible speakers, explain the objectively falsifiable implication, test whether it is materially false, retain the full headline and article context, analyze privilege and public-figure status, and preserve evidence of the speaker's knowledge or serious doubts at the time of publication. Contemporaneous editorial messages, source warnings, contradictory documents, and responses to requests for correction could matter. Separate proof would be needed for causation and recoverable losses where applicable. A claimant may seek a correction or retraction, but the legal effect of those measures varies by state.

Nothing in the public reporting reviewed for this essay establishes that a specific journalist or broadcaster knowingly published a false accusation about Jensen or Alice Huang. Nor does Fox–Dominion prove that criticism or sensational coverage in this episode is actionable. It supplies a more exacting principle: the First Amendment protects rigorous investigation and robust opinion, not the knowing or reckless publication of defamatory falsehoods. The moral argument against racialized suspicion becomes stronger—not weaker—when it respects this evidentiary boundary.

Serious objections—and why they do not resolve the concern

National security concerns can be legitimate

China has pursued cyber-espionage and technology acquisition; advanced AI hardware has substantial military relevance. Those realities justify proportionate investigation. They do not establish that a particular person is an agent. Intelligence risk assessment has a lower evidentiary threshold than criminal conviction, but the media should label the difference rather than obscure it.

Huang's personal conduct is not irrelevant

Admitted infidelity and reported relationships with employees can raise governance, judgment, conflicts, and workplace questions irrespective of ethnicity. A board can have defensible reasons for requiring a CEO's departure without establishing espionage. The criticism here is not that Huang must be reinstated, but that discussion of his departure must not rest on unproven national-security implications.

The Qian analogy has limits

Qian was deprived of liberty and mobility by the government; Huang held a private-sector leadership role and resigned. Qian's historical story is also complex and should not be reduced to a claim that every suspicion was knowingly fabricated. A meaningful historical analogy must preserve differences rather than erase them.

Prejudice must be demonstrated, not presumed

A recurring pattern of racialized suspicion is a plausible explanatory concern, particularly where nationality seems to serve as a proxy for guilt. Yet specific discriminatory motive should be established from statements, actions, comparisons, and evidence. The available record supports a critique of ethnically freighted insinuation more clearly than a blanket conclusion about the motives of American society as a whole.

Conclusion: a country should not put belonging perpetually on trial

Qian Xuesen helped advance American rocketry and then found that his position in the country had become precarious under the pressure of Cold War suspicion. Jensen Huang helped build the computational infrastructure underlying America's AI leadership, yet his 2026 downfall has been narrated in part through unresolved allegations involving China. Their circumstances differ profoundly; the underlying temptation deserves recognition.

The history of Chinese exclusion also demonstrates a more disturbing phenomenon: for some racists, Chinese success is not reassuring evidence of contribution, but an affront to an imagined racial hierarchy. The comparison between Qian and Huang is therefore not only about security panics. It is also about a society’s capacity to recognize a Chinese person’s achievements without treating their prominence as reason to question their belonging.

American scientific strength has depended on attracting people of extraordinary ability from elsewhere and allowing them to become indispensable. That promise weakens when a citizen's or resident's perceived closeness to China is treated as evidence of disloyalty without the same disciplined proof demanded in other cases.

The standard should be neither special protection for a technological hero nor special suspicion because of Chinese identity. It should be the same standard for everyone: investigate credible evidence, distinguish wrongdoing from association, report uncertainty prominently, and do not confuse legitimate economic exchange with espionage merely because it crosses a geopolitical fault line.

Qian's history shows that the consequences of abandoning those principles can outlast the panic that produced them. Huang's story is still unfolding. That makes restraint, precision and fairness more—not less—urgent.

References and methodological notes

  1. Nvidia, “NVIDIA Announces CEO Transition,” Nov. 12, 2026. Corporate history and transition statement.
  2. Caltech Aerospace, “Qian Xuesen (Tsien Hsue-shen).” Primary institutional historical biography and quoted retrospective.
  3. FBI Vault, “Hsue-Shen Tsien (Qian Xuesen), Part 02.” Declassified records documenting historical federal suspicions.
  4. Nvidia Form 8-K, filed Nov. 2026. Official record of Huang's resignation.
  5. Associated Press, “What we know after Jensen Huang resigns as Nvidia CEO,” Nov. 12, 2026. Reporting on the resignation, disclosures and allegations.
  6. CNN, “US intel isn't sure if businesswoman spied on Nvidia for China,” Nov. 12, 2026. Reporting on disputed intelligence assessments and intercepted communications.
  7. Reuters, “US Justice Department has not concluded Alice Huang was Chinese spy,” Nov. 12, 2026. Attorney General's remarks.
  8. Singapore Ministry of Home Affairs, “Singapore's Investigations into Alice Huang and Megaspeed,” Nov. 12, 2026. Primary government account of the investigation, findings, and limitations.
  9. Los Angeles Times, “Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns after his affair raises national security concerns,” Nov. 12, 2026. Example of strongly framed intelligence reporting, attributed to another outlet.
  10. Reuters, “Singapore, US agree to keep discussing Megaspeed,” Nov. 16, 2026. Current state of investigations and response from Megaspeed.
  11. U.S. Department of State, Office of the Historian, “Chinese Immigration and the Chinese Exclusion Acts.” Historical connection between Chinese economic advancement, labor resentment and exclusion.
  12. U.S. National Archives, “Chinese Exclusion Act (1882).” Primary historical account of exclusion enacted in federal law.
  13. Pew Research Center, “Asian Americans and the ‘forever foreigner’ stereotype,” 2023. Survey evidence of widespread experiences of perceived foreignness.
  14. “The Pandemic and the ‘Perpetual Foreigner’: How Threats Posed by the COVID-19 Pandemic Relate to Stereotyping of Asian Americans,” 2022. Empirical study of perceived Americanness among white American participants.
  15. New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964). Constitutional actual-malice standard for public officials, extended to public figures by subsequent case law.
  16. US Dominion, Inc. v. Fox News Network, LLC, Delaware Superior Court, March 31, 2023. Partial summary judgment on falsity and defamatory character; actual malice left for trial.
  17. In re Fox Corporation Derivative Litigation, Delaware Court of Chancery (2023). Court account of the $787.5 million Dominion settlement.
  18. US Dominion, Inc. v. Fox News Network, LLC, Delaware Superior Court (2021). Discussion of hosts, guests, contradictory evidence and asserted reporting defenses at the motion-to-dismiss stage.
  19. Harte-Hanks Communications, Inc. v. Connaughton, 491 U.S. 657 (1989). Actual malice, purposeful avoidance of the truth, and the limits of negligent reporting.
  20. Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., 497 U.S. 1 (1990). A purported opinion implying provably false defamatory facts is not categorically immune.

Scope and standard. This is an interpretive essay based on public information available through November 16, 2026. It distinguishes established facts, attributed allegations and analytical judgments. Neither the absence of public proof nor the existence of an inquiry is equivalent to an adjudication of innocence or guilt. “Prejudice” describes the historical risk and observable framing examined here; the essay does not claim to have proved discriminatory intent by any individual journalist or investigator.

Tuesday, August 05, 2025

Intel's Mass Layoffs and AMD's Future

 Can Intel survive? Doubtful. AI is the future. Even Intel's new CEO realizes that inference is Intel's last chance.

There is very enthusiastic demand for AMD's RyZEN AI MAX 395, due to its memory bandwidth. The chip can run the powerful Qwen3-30b-a3b model at the highly usable speed of around 70 tokens per second. It can run the full Qwen3-225b model at about 14 tokens/second if 2-bit quantization is used. (The Apple M4 Macbooks can achieve the same speed if equipped with sufficient unified memory.) The bigger Qwen3 is on par with OpenAI's o3, at PhD level intelligence.

On the client side, AMD should focus on bringing more of such local AI capabilities. Imagine future AMD PCes come builtin with PhD level AI right in the box, people will be willing to pay premium prices.


Thursday, February 17, 2022

Thoughts on AMD's Rembrandt Laptop Benchmarks

 AMD is doing so well on all fronts. EPYC is killing Xeon in datacenter.

AMD's more 50% share of the FPGA market will surely generate a multiplicative expansion of its products and market share.

But I am noticing a trend by the reviewers and wondering whether they are being paid by team blue.

In the Rembrandt laptop reviews, those 3 lb AMD laptops are compared to 6.4 pound Intel Alder Lake ones, as if they belong to the same catgeory. This is totally unacceptable. In any laptop, the CPU+RAM+NVME storage has about the same small weight. That 3 pounds of extra weight in the Intel machine is largely for handling the excessive heat and larger battery.  The 6.x pound Intel laptop is heavier than some desktop PCs. Anyone carrying such a bulky machine in Starbucks will surely draw some scornful looks from the civilized coffee drinkers, and will probably be pushed outside when its loud fans starts emitting shrieking noises.

Why are reviewers doing such invalid benchmark comparisons? They can't fool their readers, they most likely offend their readers.






Friday, August 20, 2021

The AMD64 Revolution Is Almost Accomplished, But Not Yet

 I haven't posted for a while. Because my posts were forward-looking, to tell you what was to come, not to state the obvious. AMD is winning, there is no need for me to repeat that fact.

But I must now state the obvious.

"The revolution has yet to be completed, comarades must still work hard." Those were the words told by Dr. Sun Yatsien. And Dr. Lisa Su must have heard of those words.

AMD must make decisive and forceful moves to finish the job.



Friday, November 09, 2018

Reflections on the AMD Revolution

The AMD-Intel struggle is nothing short of biblical in the world of computing.

Ever since the Athlon days, AMD has always been the innovator and Intel has always been the follower.

In 2001, AMD moved from shared front bus to point-to-point interconnect, the HyperTransport. Intel followed in 2008, with its QuickPath interconnect. NUMA became the norm.

In 2003, AMD launched the first AMD64 processor, the Opteron server chip with 64-bit extensions to x86. Intel eventually abandoned its dear-to-heart Itanium plans to followed suit. Nowadays, Intel Xeon and Core chips are all based on AMD64.

Similarly, Intel followed AMD's footsteps on other technological advances, such as IMC (embedded memory controller) and multi-core.

It would seem that Intel simply waited for AMD the innovator, and then moved up to copy and eat AMD's lunch. Intel was able to thrive on such parasitic strategy due to its size and monopolistic control of the market. It used to take AMD three to four years to gain meaningful market share, while Intel leisurely and unabashedly copy-catted the true innovator. When benchmark manipulation was no longer viable, Intel simply paid OEMs not to use AMD.

History seems to repeat itself. When AMD unleashed the EPYC ZEN architecture with four 8-core chips forming a massive 32-core/64 thread server CPU laden with advanced security features and vast I/O bandwidth in 2017, Intel ridiculed AMD for gluing four desktop chips into a server chip. The IT press was not amused. Intel's arrogant ignorance was universally condemned.

Now, EPYC Rome's revolutionary Zen 2 architecture has been partially unveiled.  With eight 7nm 8-core Zen core chiplets embracing a central I/O chip, AMD once again thought out of the box. It moved away from NUMA (at least in 1P) and achieved something beyond the imagination of the Intel engineers. AMD never ceases to amaze us,  so little resource, yet so much innovation.

The unimaginative Intel engineers are now being commanded by former AMD architects, with Jim Keller and Raja Koduri being the more notable ones. To counter the onslaught of the mighty Rome, a rash plan was hatched to glue two massive 700 mm^2 old Xeon dies to compose the so called Cascade Lake CPU. Essentially, Intel is cramping a 2-P server into a 1P socket, without the forethought of the chiplet technology. Unfortunately for Intel, it does not enjoy the power and density advantage of a 7nm process. The truly glued together Cascade Lake will have a heat production of over 350 watts, sufficient to fry your breakfast egg in minutes. Intel is desperate. Firing its veteran CEO doesn't seem to help. The old Intel machine with its internal bureaucracy and internal politics would resist any infusion of external blood. The situation spells doom for the blue team.

But if history repeats itself, would Intel suppress AMD again to buy time like it did in the Opteron days?

The current situation is different because of three reasons.

First, the anti-trust lawsuit launched by Hector Ruiz has constrained Intel's unlawful tactics. Intel was convicted and fined by the U.S. and EU governments. Dell was chastised for taking the bribes. AMD gained the right to outsource its wafer fabrication. If Intel were to do something naughty, it would have to be more subtle, such as hiding a weighty water chiller under the table for its 5GHz 28-core demo.

Second, Intel has lost the process lead as we approach the physical limits of optical wavelength and atomic radius. TSMC is moving towards 5nm and 3nm. Intel is still struggling with 10nm.

Third, AMD has learned its lessons. In the Opteron days, Henri Richard bragged about his fancy new car afforded by the elevated AMD stock price and boasted that Intel would never catch up. AMD was cocky those days. But BullDozer was a disaster. Intel overtook AMD with raw instructions per clock. Now, Dr. Lisa Su is not letting up her feet on the engine paddle. AMD fellow Mike Clark revealed in an interview that he was working on Zen 5. People conjectured that AMD skipped Zen 4 because of a Chinese superstition. Untrue! AMD is near completion on Zen 3. Zen 4 is underway. And we knew months ago, Zen 5 had been started.

Hail Caeser! Hail AMD!





Thursday, June 14, 2018

AMD Winning in Mobile Space

AMD is grabbing mobile big time. Susquehanna is misinformed or misinforming. AMD's presence in the Laptop market has never been stronger. There are now many premium consumer and commercial laptop designs from HP, Dell and Lenovo. Just search for RyZEN on their websites. On HP.com alone, you find the following AMD RyZEN notebooks: HP EliteBook 735 (13.3"), HP EliteBook 745, EliteBook 755, HP ProBook 645, HP Envy x360 15 (15.6"), HP Envy x360 13 (13.3").... Dell has a slew of 13, 15, 17 notebooks powered by AMD RyZEN . Lenovo has the 2.5 lb 720s with RyZEN and is launching more. We have never seen AMD with such strong presence in the premium highend notebook space. AMD was previously only in the lowest end. Notebook is more than half of client computing. AMD will make much bigger profit in this sector.

Thursday, January 04, 2018

Intel Meltdown Reshapes the x64 Computing Landscape

Finally, the picture has been set straight. Let me summarize.

1) The Intel Meltdown hole is on the galactic scale. You didn't see me jumping up about the Intel trust management bug, because that can be fixed in software. This Intel Meltdown hole is in the silicon logic. The Meltdown flaw is fatal, as it enables a small user application to silently read all system memory, including kernel memory and even kernel memory of another virtual machine, all without leaving any trace.

2) The OS fix for Meltdown is very costly, up to 50% performance hit. Worse, the hit increases with higher end hardware. If you use super expensive NVME drives, the percentage loss in performance will be bigger, as more context switches are need to trap into the kernel, where the Intel Meltdown flaw necessitates flush of the cache on XEON and i7 CPUs. Moreover, I am not sure that the OS fix such as KPTI completely solves the problem.

3) The future fix in the silicon will take Intel about a year. When that happens, I project that Intel's IPC (instructions per clock) be lower by about as much as 15%. Intel has taken all sorts of unsound shortcuts to get higher IPC, relying on the naive assumption that code behaves nicely. The Intel Core now has about 5% IPC advantage over the AMD ZEN architecture. That advantage will vaporize when Intel performs proper checks before speculative execution.

4) AMD has done a very good job in implementing valid execution logic and in security. Most signicantly, AMD is immune from the Meltdown, the most serious flaw that can be easily exploited by any script kiddie. AMD led the industry into x64 computing with its rock solid Opteron. With the disgraceful demise of the XEON, the AMD EPYC stands to be the only enterprise worthy x64 chip for a long time. The RyZEN desktop CPU is in fact an EPYC server CPU with enterprise features disabled. AMD means reliability, quality and security.

5) Financial projection: Intel's damages can hardly be underestimated, as class action lawsuits are looming from all angles from shareholder derivative, consumer, enterprise customer to indemnification. SEC may look into some of the insider trades. In addition to the loss of reputation and market share, how Intel compensates for the defective CPUs and loss of performance is unclear. Since the Intel Meltdown is a design flaw that can be avoided (as AMD did), Intel may be strictly liable for all damages caused by Meltdown.

Tuesday, November 21, 2017

Hackers Can Remotely Control Intel Servers -- Even if they are turned off

According to the Hacker News, there are massive security flaws in the Management Engine of Intel servers. One of the security hole is CVE-2017-5705). It has multiple buffer overflow issues in the operating system kernel for Intel ME Firmware that could allow attackers to "load and execute code outside the visibility of the user and operating system."

The piece states that "As long as the system is connected to a line power and a network cable, these remote functions can be performed out of band even when the computer is turned off as it operates independently of the operating system."

The worst thing is that such security breaches can be done without the knowledge of system administrators, because they execute in the firmware that manages and controls the server hardware and software.

Read more at https://thehackernews.com/2017/11/intel-chipset-flaws.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed:+TheHackersNews+

Monday, November 13, 2017

TensorFlow for AMD Radeon Will Break Nvidia Monopoly

Nvdia has established a virtual monopoly in the artificial intelligence and machine learning arena through its CUDA. Jensen Huang openly acknowledged this. When asked by analysts what Nvidia's advantages are in the AI/ML world, Huang said it's about CUDA. Indeed, the most popular ML framework, TensorFlow, supports CUDA and thus Nvidia GPUs only. Even if you are an AMD loyalist and have bought an AMD VEGA GPU, if you want to do some TensorFlow or Keras work today, you need a NVIDIA GPU. A GTX 1060 seems to be the minimum requirement for AI. But things are changing.

The lack of ML software support in AMD GPUs has attracted attention. A company named Vertex.AI has released an open source machine learning engine called PlaidML. It is based on OpenCL and its initial benchmarks show great promise for AMD Radeon, which has superior compute performance. Unfortunately, plaidML is still in development and lacks support for recurrent neural networks.

Today, AMD announced that its new ROCm 1.7 and MIOpen library will have TensorFlow support. Since Keras runs on top of TensorFlow, Radeon owners can also enjoy their GPU's AI power with a much nicer and easier to use programming interface.

What does this mean for Nvidia? Its near monopoly in AI/ML will be broken. Nvidia will have to share the fledgling AI market with AMD.

This is no less than a sea change. Coupled with Intel's adoption of AMD GPU technology in its mobile platforms, Nvidia's revenue will suffer intolerance decline and its lebensraum will see rapid shrinking.

Wednesday, May 17, 2017

Can Intel Price War With AMD's EPYC RyZEN

A common and naive misconception of the Intel and AMD rivalry is that Intel can always conduct a price war against AMD. Macquarie Research's Srini Pajjuri asserts that "[a]ny share gains by AMD will likely be met with aggressive pricing actions by Intel, which could severely limit AMD's margin expansion hopes." Such view is way too simplistic. Intel does not have the freedom to arbitrarily lower prices. In fact, since the RyZEN launch, we have not seen any major price reduction by Intel. Why?
The reason is simple. Doing so would lead to the implosion of Intel's revenue and profits, something Intel can't do and will not do.
Consider the limit in which Intel lowered all of its product prices to $0 and gave away its products for free for a year for the purpose of limiting AMD's market expansion (assuming no regulatory restraints and shareholders are silent). Intel's revenue would be $0 for a year, and suffers billions of dollars in losses. AMD's Ryzen 7 1800X would have to surrender to the now free i7 6950k. But still, there would be people willing to pay AMD a hefty premium for the 32 Core EPYC and ThreadRipper 16 core CPUs that Intel can't offer. And the Xbox and PS4 game console business will continue to maintain a lower level survival for AMD.
As you can see from this extreme scenario, when AMD commands the top tier, Intel's price war will hurt itself more. A reasonable assumption is that any pricing action by Intel will tend to maintain its own revenue and profitability levels.
In his AMD May 16, 2017 Financial Analyst Day presentation, Jim Anderson showed the key statistics that can provide analytical insight into the competitive landscape: 45% of the PC units are in the mainstream and below market, but generate only 21% of the revenue; 55% of the PC units are in the premium segment, but generate 79% of the revenue.
Let ASPm be to the average selling price (NYSE:ASP) of a mainstream & below CPU, and ASPp be the ASP of a premium CPU, U being the total units, and REV be to total revenue. We have:
REV = ( 45% * ASPm + 55% * ASPp) * U
Now, assuming Intel performs a price adjument in the premium segment by a factor of F, the total revenue will be (assuming the ratio of premiumum PCes stay the same):
REV = ( 45% * ASPm + 55% * F* ASPp) * U
Thus, the change in revenue will be:
dREV/REV = 0.55*(F-1)*ASPp/[ 45% * ASPm + 55% * ASPp]
Currently,
ASPm * 45% * U = 0.21 * REV
ASPp * 55% * U = 0.79 * REV
Therefore, ASPp = 45/55 * 79/21 * ASPm = 3.07 ASPm. In other words, the ASP of premium CPU is 3x of the mainstream/below CPUs. And,
dREV/REV = 0.79* (F-1)
Assmuning Intel cuts its premium CPU prices by 20%, i.e., F = 0.8, then the change in TOTAL revenue will be
dREV/REV = 0.79 * (0.8 -1) = -15.8 %.
In other words, if Intel cut its premium product ASP by 20%, Intel's total revenue will fall 15.8%.
You may ask, what happened in the past? There were two scenarios.
When AMD could only compete in the mainstream/below market, Intel could cut prices in the lower end to limit AMD, while slightly increasing ASP in the premium segment to maintain its own revenue/profits.
When AMD commanded the premium segment with the AMD64 and Opteron, Intel resorted to anti-competitive means to limit AMD's access to the market. Intel was later fined over a billion dollars and paid AMD roughly a billion dollars in settlement, but the damage had been done.
Today, the situation is different. AMD commands the price/performance in the premium market, and Intel's anti-competition practices are more or less under control.
For Intel, market share loss is inevitable. What can Intel do?
To maintain its revenue level, Intel will have to INCREASE prices.
It is simple math.
Disclosure: I am/we are long AMD.

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Comment on Mantle Boost

Joel ,

You ought to take a lesson in logical reasoning.

Mantle mostly helps in "CPU bound" situation does lead to a conclusion that "it’s actually for boosting low-end CPUs."

CPU-bound vs. GPU-bound is a relative comparison of a GPU and a CPU. While low-end CPU is the result of a comparison between CPUs. One measure (CPU/GPU) simply cannot lead to another (CPU/CPU).

You could have a PC with the highest end CPU currently available, but still being CPU-bound due to the GPU being even more powerful. In such a case, Mantle will offer big gains. Similarly, you could have a low-end Celeron paired with a even lower GPU, and Mantle will help a bit but not much.

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

AMD 1Q04 Guidance Up 25% YoY

AMD had the great 4Q03, which showed a 9% sequential growth from 3Q03.
1Q04 will be down sequentially, but is guided up 25% from 1Q03, from 1.09 billion of revenue in 1Q 2013 to 1.36 billion in 1Q 2014.

AMD put the 8-core Jaguar AMD64 APUs used in XB1 and PS4 into the Graphics category. If you count the XB1 and PS4 as CPUs, you see AMD CPU business increasing at a 40% rate. This is AMD's way of getting more business without alerting Intel, which is a one-trick-pony, but has the resources to acquire the necessary IP. PC business is in perpetual decline. AMD's strategy is to become an chip solutions provider, not a PC component maker.

AMD is no longer endangered by Intel's price wars and illegal marketing ploys. With 55% of its revenue from the non-computing solutions group, AMD has disengaged from Intel's claws. 

AMD's marketing cap is 50% of its revenue. NVDA has less revenue than AMD, but its market cap is 3x of AMD. If AMD can distance itself from the declining PC market, its valuation should be at the same level of NVIDIA or more. The Shorts of AMD like you to treat AMD as a dying company. But AMD has stabilized on its own turf, and is thriving on its broad IP portfolio, which can't be matched by Intel.

Friday, January 17, 2014

Now Intel is fragged

ExtremeTech  shows HSA enabled AMD Kaveri frags Intel Haswell i5-4670S by being almost 500% faster in a LibreOffice Calc test


Thursday, January 09, 2014

AMD is no longer just a chips provider

It has become a solutions provider.

It is on a different level from one-trick-ponies such as INTEL and NVIDIA.

NVDA is dead man walking. It lost the gaming market, as the gaming industry standardizing around AMD hardware and APIs; it lost a major chunk of the pro graphics market; it is far behind in OpenCL performance; and it is the hopeless underdog in cryptocurrency mining.

Once HSA gets more software support, Intel will also find its x86 cores no match to AMD APUs.

Tuesday, December 24, 2013

The genie is now out of the bottle

"The shorts are playing with fire," says one Seeking Alpha reader. Yes. They totally misunderstood and underestimated AMD, which has the broadest and greatest IP assets in the WHOLE semiconductor industry. No other company on the planet can match AMD in terms of IP wealth and innovation. For years, Intel spent huge amounts of cash to suppress to contain AMD. Intel paid billions of dollars to the vendors for not using AMD, while copycatting all the AMD innovations-- from x64 to multi-core. Containment failed. The genie is now out of the bottle. 

In the new chip-convergence era, the world finds that AMD and ONLY AMD has all the necessary IP blocks by itself. 64 bit server strength compute (AMD64, ccHT, IMC), GPGPU, Fabric and the architecture to link these together. Micorosoft and SONY chose AMD not because they love Intel+Nvidia less, but because ONLY AMD has the technologies. Both Intel and Nvidia are essentially on-trick-ponies in a convergence world.

AMD's wins in the PS4 and XB1 are just the beginning.


Shorts@AMD can expect to lose a USD$5.5 billion total.

Friday, December 20, 2013

AMD Mantle is gonna smother Intel Haswell

Oxide says


See https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=QIWyf8Hyjbg

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Litecoin Millionaires-to-be are flocking to the mine

Ordered four AMD R9 290s last night, there were five in stock, quickly made an order, and got the following message in the morning:

****************************************************************
AN IMPORTANT MESSAGE ABOUT YOUR ORDER

We're sorry, but although your order was in stock at the time it was placed, it is now out of stock and cannot be shipped at this time.  We regret any inconvenience.
****************************************************************
----------------------------------------------------------------
Order was entered on Wednesday, December 11, 2013
Items Ordered
---------------
R9 290 4GD5 MSI Video Card R9 290 4GD5 Hawaii Pro 4GB DDR5 PCIE3.0 Retail [MSTI0J1] - (Qty 4)
- Was originally in stock, but is now out of stock.
----------------------------------------------------------------


Why?

You could get rich quick by mining Litecoins. An AMD R9 290 can mine 15 Litecoins in a month, that's over 600 USD of value, minus 100 or so electricity cost, the profit is about $500/month. With 20 such GPUs, the profit becomes $10,000/month.

Quick road to six figure income without any education requirement.

Both Xbox One and PS4 should be very good mining rigs if software is available. I wonder AMD Mantle could improve mining power.

PS: on eBay the R9 290 sells for $1000